New Leadership and Strategic Shifts Drive Hope Amid Challenges
Victoria’s Secret & Co. (VSCO) is entering a critical phase in its recovery journey, as a recent upgrade to “Equal Weight” from “Underweight” reflects a more balanced risk-reward scenario for the lingerie giant. Despite past challenges, the company retains a significant position in the U.S. intimates market, controlling roughly 20%, which is now seen as defensible under new leadership and strategic direction. While much work remains, key changes point toward the potential for stabilization and growth, albeit with cautionary optimism.
New Leadership: A Catalyst for Change
One of the pivotal reasons for the upgrade is the appointment of Hillary Super as the new CEO, effective from September 2024. Super brings nearly three decades of experience in retail merchandising, women’s apparel, and category management, making her a fitting choice to steer the brand back to its core heritage. Her expertise in understanding Victoria’s Secret’s core consumer is expected to lead to a more targeted approach in product innovation and marketing.
However, the company remains a “show-me” story, with investors and analysts waiting for tangible results before fully backing the turnaround. This leadership change comes as VSCO eliminates executive roles like Brand President and Chief Customer Officer, reflecting an effort to streamline operations and sharpen focus. While this organizational shift holds promise, the impact of these changes will likely become more evident in 2025.
2H24 Consensus Expectations: Room for Upside
Victoria’s Secret’s financial outlook for the second half of 2024 also plays a key role in the upgrade. Management’s guidance suggests a more optimistic view than consensus expectations, indicating that the worst may be behind the company. Full-year guidance was raised during the 2Q24 earnings call, with projections for sales down only 1%, outperforming consensus expectations of a 1.6% decline. Additionally, adjusted earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) for the year are expected to fall between $275 million and $300 million, giving the company room to meet or exceed these figures.
In 3Q24, guidance points to an adjusted loss per share (LPS) between $(0.80) and $(0.60), aligning with or slightly better than consensus projections. This cautious optimism signals that the company could experience upside potential if it can deliver stronger-than-expected results through the holiday season.
Returning to Core Brand Roots
One of the most promising aspects of the turnaround strategy is Victoria’s Secret’s renewed focus on its core brand identity and product innovation. For years, the brand has struggled to maintain relevance in a competitive market, but recent signs of stabilization, particularly in North America, suggest that the company is beginning to reverse this trend.
Sales trends have improved in both physical stores and digital channels, with new product lines driving growth. Notable successes include the Victoria’s Secret Dream bra and new fragrance launches like Tease Sugar Fleur, which have generated positive customer response. In addition, the company is bringing back its iconic fashion show in October 2024, signaling a return to its roots while modernizing its image.
The brand’s emphasis on product newness, coupled with efforts to rebuild its relationship with core customers, could help drive further stabilization. However, sustained sales growth and market share recovery are critical factors that investors will be watching closely.
Product Margin Recovery: A Key Driver for Long-Term Success
Another positive sign is the potential for margin recovery, driven by a sales-to-inventory inflection that began in 4Q23. Victoria’s Secret has worked to clear aged inventory and replace it with fresh, high-margin products. Proprietary inventory analysis shows three consecutive quarters of positive sales-to-inventory growth, which could signal a sustained merchandise margin recovery.
The company’s Gross Margin Return on Inventory Investment (GMROI) has also improved over the past three quarters, suggesting that its inventory is becoming more productive. This is further supported by an improved Operating Margin Return on Inventory (OMROI) in 2Q24, hinting at potential for stronger profitability in the months ahead.
Cautionary Notes: Risks Remain
Despite these positive developments, risks remain that could derail the recovery. Key challenges include uncertainty around whether new product launches will resonate with customers at scale, the need for sustained positive sales growth, and external pressures such as a challenging consumer backdrop that could lead to continued promotional activity. Additionally, while the integration of AdoreMe could bring incremental upside, it remains to be seen how well this will complement the company’s broader strategy.
Victoria’s Secret’s turnaround is still a work in progress, with management execution on key strategic pillars being essential to regaining market share and driving long-term growth. Until these factors materialize, cautious optimism is warranted.
Conclusion: A Balanced Outlook
Victoria’s Secret is navigating a delicate balance between recovery and ongoing challenges. The upgrade to Equal Weight reflects a more positive, yet cautious outlook as new leadership, product innovation, and inventory management offer potential for stabilization. While the road to full recovery may extend into 2025, investors are starting to see a clearer path forward for the brand that once dominated the intimates market. The key question remains: Can Victoria’s Secret deliver on its promises and regain the trust of its core customers? Only time will tell.
You might like this article:BlackRock and Microsoft Join Forces for $100 Billion AI Infrastructure Investment
